ML dog shooting case reverses

Print Article

CBH Columbia Basin Herald Local News

SEATTLE - A lawsuit surrounding the 2010 dog shooting by a Grant County sheriff's deputy will return to federal court.

In April 2012, U.S. District Court Judge Lonny Suko dismissed Nicholas Criscuolo's lawsuit against Grant County, according to a previous Columbia Basin Herald article.

Criscuolo was at Neppel Landing Park in January 2010 with his dog, Slyder, and another dog. Deputy Beau Lamens then arrived at the park with a drug-detection dog, Maddox, to assist in an arrest, according to the article.

Slyder ran up to Maddox, and the two dogs began fighting. Lamens kicked Slyder in an attempt to separate the dogs, then shot Slyder, according to the article.

In his lawsuit, Criscuolo claimed Lamens violated his Fourth Amendment rights by shooting Slyder. Suko dismissed the lawsuit, ruling the shooting was reasonable.

According to Suko's decision, "The court must conclude the governmental interest (protecting Maddox) constitutes the prevailing interest in this case."

Criscuolo and his attorney Adam Karp appealed the decision, taking the matter to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals earlier this year. Judges issued a decision last week, reversing part of Judge Suko's ruling.

Judges found the district court erred in determining Lamens' killing of Slyder was objectively reasonable, according to court documents.

"Viewing the totality of the circumstances in the light most favorable to Criscuolo...the killing was not reasonably necessary to protect the safety of Maddox, the police dog," read the decision.

According to the decision, Slyder posed no imminent threat to Maddox, even though the events occurred rapidly.

Criscuolo and other witnesses claimed that right before Lamens fired, Slyder was not springing toward Maddox, but was instead stationary or retreating at a distance of 10 to 20 feet from Lamens and Maddox. Criscuolo was also one to two feet away and about to leash Slyder, according to the decision.

"A reasonable jury could conclude that Lamens did not need to make any 'split-second decision' to protect Maddox," read the decision.

A new trial date has not been set yet, Karp said.

Attorney Jerry Moberg, who represents the county, said the Court of Appeals didn't rule that Lamens' actions were reasonable or unreasonable. Instead, they ruled that it was really up to a jury to decide, he said.

"All the court really said was that it may be a question of fact for the jury to decide whether the officer's actions were reasonable under the circumstances," Moberg said.

Moberg said he is confident a jury will conclude Lamens' actions were reasonable after hearing the facts.

"With the judge (Suko) determining in his view that the officer acted in a reasonable fashion, I believe a jury will too," he said.

Print Article

Read More News

UK Parliament investigates cyberattack on user accounts

AP

June 24, 2017 at 10:09 am | LONDON (AP) British officials were investigating a cyberattack Saturday on the country's Parliament after discovering "unauthorized attempts to access parliamentary user accounts." A statement ...

Comments

Read More

Over 120 people buried by massive southwest China landslide

AP

June 24, 2017 at 10:02 am | BEIJING (AP) More than 120 people were buried by a landslide that caused huge rocks and a mass of earth to come crashing into their homes in a mountain village in southwestern China early Saturday,...

Comments

Read More

UK fire safety crisis expands; Hundreds evacuated in London

AP

June 24, 2017 at 10:02 am | LONDON (AP) Britain's fire-safety crisis expanded substantially Saturday as authorities revealed that 27 high-rise apartment blocks across the country have cladding that failed fire safety tests. L...

Comments

Read More

AP Top International News at 1:03 p.m. EDT

AP

June 24, 2017 at 10:10 am | Jordan to cancel 'marry the victim' clause shielding rapists...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(509) 765-4561
PO Box 910
Moses Lake, WA 98837

©2017 Columbia Basin Herald Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X
X